In today’s market research landscape, understanding consumer behavior goes beyond traditional methods. At Threadline, we believe in delving deeper into the narratives that shape how consumers perceive and interact with brands. In this post, we’ll explore how the field of narrative psychology reveals the powerful stories consumers tell themselves—and how these stories influence their purchasing decisions.
The Power of Narrative Psychology
Narrative psychology is a branch of psychology that explores how people use stories to make sense of their lives, identities, and the world around them. This approach is especially relevant in understanding consumer behavior because it emphasizes the importance of the stories that people construct about their experiences with brands.
When we think about brands, we often consider their features, benefits, and the emotions they evoke. However, narrative psychology suggests that consumers are not just buying products for what they do or how they make them feel. They are also buying into the stories these brands allow them to tell about themselves and others. This concept is central to what we at Threadline call the narrative economy.
“If you want to know me, then you must know my story, for my story defines who I am.”
Dan McAdams, PhD
From Jobs-to-Be-Done to Stories-to-Be-Told
Many marketers are familiar with the Jobs-to-Be-Done framework, which helps identify the functional and emotional jobs that a product or service fulfills for a consumer. While this framework is undoubtedly useful, it doesn’t capture the full picture. We propose a new framework: Stories-to-Be-Told.
This framework goes beyond the functional jobs a product performs. It focuses on how the product integrates into the consumer’s life story. Consumers aren’t just making decisions based on what a product does; they are influenced by the stories they can tell through their interactions with the brand. These stories help them make sense of their identities and how they want to be perceived by others.
The Inclusion of the Other into the Self
One of the most profound concepts in narrative psychology is the inclusion of the other into the self. This idea, rooted in interpersonal relationships, suggests that as relationships deepen, the identities of the individuals involved start to merge. Their experiences, joys, and pains become shared to the point where they are almost indistinguishable from each other.
This concept applies to brand relationships as well. When consumers form deep connections with brands, they start to incorporate those brands into their identities. The stories they tell about themselves often include the brands they love and trust. Over time, these brands become an integral part of their life narratives.
Moving Beyond Traditional Research: Eliciting Stories
Traditional market research methods often rely on asking direct questions that seek to extract specific information from consumers. While this approach can yield useful data, it has significant limitations. Consumers are not always aware of the true motivations behind their decisions, and they are often poor at predicting their future behavior.
At Threadline, we advocate for a shift from interrogating questions to narrative prompts. Instead of asking consumers why they made a particular choice, we encourage them to tell us a story about their experience. This approach taps into the part of the brain that naturally recalls and recounts experiences, leading to richer, more meaningful insights.
For example, rather than asking someone why they booked an Airbnb, we might prompt them to tell us the story of their last Airbnb booking. This narrative approach reveals not just the practical reasons behind their choice, but also the emotional and cultural significance of their decision. It allows us to understand how the experience of staying in an Airbnb fits into their broader travel narrative, offering insights that traditional research methods might miss.
Case Studies: Applying Narrative Research
Let’s take a closer look at how narrative research can uncover deeper insights:
Airbnb: Immersing in Culture
In our research with Airbnb users, traditional questions about their reasons for choosing an Airbnb yielded predictable responses—cost, convenience, and amenities. However, when we asked participants to tell the story of their last Airbnb booking, a richer narrative emerged. Travelers expressed that Airbnb allowed them to feel more immersed in the local culture, offering a more authentic experience than a hotel. This insight highlights how Airbnb fits into their broader travel story, providing not just a place to stay, but a way to live like a local.
“Airbnbs allow you to feel more immersed in the culture. Travel is about getting away, but hotels sanitize the experience so you feel like you could be anywhere.”
LifeWeb 360: Mourning with Dignity
In another project, we explored how the online platform LifeWeb 360 helps people mourn loved ones virtually. Traditional research questions might have focused on the practical benefits of the platform, such as the ability to share news during the pandemic. However, when we elicited stories from users, we uncovered much deeper emotional narratives. Users shared that LifeWeb 360 allowed them to bring their community together, transcending geographic boundaries and expanding their understanding of their loved one’s life through shared stories. This platform became a vital part of their mourning process, revealing the emotional and relational impact that traditional research might overlook.
“Wakes and memorials are for the rest of us. To share stories, to cry together, to laugh together. I needed a way to bring her community together no matter how far away they were.”
The Future of Market Research: Embracing Narrative Insights
It’s clear that incorporating narrative psychology into our methods can provide a more holistic understanding of consumers. By focusing on the stories people tell about their experiences with brands, we can uncover the deeper motivations and emotions that drive their behavior.
At Threadline, we are committed to helping brands uncover these hidden narratives. By shifting from traditional research methods to narrative prompts, we can gain insights that not only inform marketing strategies but also build stronger, more meaningful connections between brands and consumers.
Conclusion: Telling the Right Stories
In a world where consumers are bombarded with information and choices, the brands that stand out are those that resonate on a deeper, narrative level. Understanding and integrating into the stories consumers tell about themselves and the world around them is key to building lasting brand relationships.
As we continue to explore the power of narrative psychology in our work at Threadline, we invite you to join us in this journey. Let’s move beyond surface-level insights and start uncovering the stories that truly drive consumer behavior.
Sign up for industry updates: